Why do intelligent people keep making stupid decisions?: 8 Deadly Sins in Football and Leadership — and How to Avoid Them

by Jon Morten Melhus (Author), Morten Eriksen-Deinoff (Author)  

Format: Kindle, Pocket and Hardcover

Order the book her.

---

If football is a business, why isn’t it run like one?

This is not a book about tactics. You won’t find formations, transfer analysis or match-day strategy here. Instead, this book explains why intelligent, well-resourced football clubs keep making the same irrational decisions — and introduces original leadership frameworks, several of them presented in a football book for the first time, to help clubs break the pattern.

Drawing on eleven years of research, behavioural science and real-life case studies from clubs around the world, MBAs Jon Morten Melhus and Morten Eriksen-Deinoff show that football’s biggest failures do not begin on the pitch. They begin in the boardroom.

Filled with passion, ambition, extraordinary talent and finances sometimes resembling those of a small country, the game should be a model of excellence. But when the authors compared football clubs with high-performing organisations outside sport, they found that football repeatedly ignores many of the leadership principles that create sustainable success everywhere else.

They discovered why — and how clubs can avoid:

• Hiring the wrong coaches — and firing them just months later.
• Confusing authority with leadership.
• Letting short-term panic override long-term strategy.
• Rewarding a coaching style that most successful organisations abandoned years ago.

Inside, you’ll find four frameworks unique to this book:

• The Gang of Four — a governance model that keeps a club’s key decision-makers aligned, so a run of bad results doesn’t trigger a panicked sacking.
• Coach A vs Coach B — a practical way to identify, before you hire, which coaches are equipped to build high-performing teams over the long term rather than deliver a quick bounce.
• The Gorilla Coach — drawing on Geert Hofstede’s research into national culture, it explains why authoritarian coaches are hired more readily in high-masculinity, high-power-distance countries — and why that instinct usually backfires.
• The AMIGO Method — a structured approach to building the kind of positive, inclusive culture where employees and players actually perform.

You’ll also discover:

• Why replacing coaches rarely solves a club’s real problems — and what successful clubs do differently.
• Why supporters often push clubs towards decisions that undermine the very success they are trying to create.
• Why Guardiola, Klopp, Wenger and Ancelotti have built enduring success — while many celebrated authoritarian coaches struggle to achieve the same in today’s football.
• How the One Second Rule helps explain why teams require years — not months — to reach their full potential.
• Why football’s biggest problems are rarely about football — and how understanding human behaviour changes everything.
• A practical blueprint for developing Coach Bs — using modern, transformational approaches to build trust, unlock the potential of both Gen Z and more experienced players, and sustain high performance over the long term.

Combining compelling football stories, humour, psychology and practical leadership tools, this book provides an evidence-based roadmap for building better-led clubs, stronger cultures and more successful teams. Whether you are a chairman, CEO, sporting director, coach, player, supporter — or simply fascinated by what makes teams and organisations succeed — this book will fundamentally change the way you look at football.

And while rooted in football, its lessons extend far beyond sport. Football is simply the world’s most visible laboratory for leading under pressure. The same emotions, cognitive biases, power struggles and poor decision-making that shape football clubs also shape businesses, boardrooms and politics — only in football they unfold faster, louder and under the brightest lights.